“You Need Someone Who Is Exclusively on Your Side”: Lawyer Giovanna Salvucci on Buying Property in Italy

By Patrick · 2026-11-16

Giovanna Salvucci has been a lawyer for almost 35 years and runs her practice in Civitanova Marche. For around 30 years she has advised mainly foreign buyers. We met her in the Marche region, in the very landscape where many of our readers dream of owning a home. We talked to her about the two contracts, the difference between a lawyer and a notary, and the pitfalls that foreign buyers can easily overlook.

Patrick: Giovanna, a few days ago we asked our neighbour Conny how she bought her house. She had no lawyer, just a notary, and was happy with that. We were very glad that we had one. Why is that so important?

Giovanna: First you need to understand how a purchase works in Italy. Unlike in Germany, you don't sign one contract but two: first the preliminary contract, the contratto preliminare, also called the compromesso, and then the notarial deed of sale, the atto pubblico.

Rainer: And what's the difference? Why do you need two contracts?

Giovanna: Because in Italy only the notarial deed transfers ownership from seller to buyer. In the preliminary contract, both sides commit to obligations. That is where the negotiation happens and where clauses and conditions are set. Afterwards those obligations are fulfilled, and once all conditions have been met, the contract is essentially repeated before the notary as a public deed, with a few additions.

Rainer: So the real work happens before the notary.

Giovanna: Exactly. The heart of the matter is the preliminary contract. The notary can no longer change what the parties agreed there about works, documents or particular features of the property. That is the phase in which a lawyer can achieve the most for the buyer. The notary comes afterwards. He receives a copy of the registered preliminary contract, carries out the final checks on registrations and encumbrances on the property, and executes the contract. He doesn't usually spend hours advising one party individually.

Patrick: You say “a lawyer”. What exactly does he take on in this phase?

Giovanna: He takes responsibility for the security of the transaction. If something is wrong, the lawyer is responsible. He checks that the seller is actually the owner you are negotiating with. He checks that the property is free of encumbrances. For a house in the countryside, he looks at whether there are pre-emption rights or easements. On maps you sometimes see old municipal roads crossing private land. Then there are procedures that need to be started.

Patrick: In our case, for example, it was about whether the access road to the house belongs to the farmer or to the municipality. As a foreigner you can hardly find that out yourself.

Giovanna: Exactly. That is why foreign clients in particular hire me. They want someone impartial who is exclusively on their side.

Rainer: Many parties are involved in a purchase: agents, surveyors, sellers, buyers, the notary, often the bank too. And everyone has their own interests.

Giovanna: Yes, and that's the point. In Italy an agent may represent the interests of both sides and receives a commission from both. Some buyers therefore feel he isn't entirely on their side, because he wants to close the deal quickly and mediate between the interests. The lawyer has no interest in any particular house. If you don't buy it, it makes no difference to me. What matters to me is trust and a secure transaction. Often that relationship of trust is renewed with the next purchase.

Patrick: I have to say, our buyers are exactly the people who come to Trovara for advice. That's why I find this so important. A lawyer who also tells you when something isn't as good as it sounds.

Giovanna: That is his job. He tells you everything, including the problems. And he immediately tells you how they can be solved. Naming a problem without offering a solution helps nobody. The client rightly asks: so what do we do now?

Rainer: Do you have an example of where the interests of agent and buyer really differ?

Giovanna: The deposit, the caparra. I advise paying it only into the notary's escrow account, the conto dedicato. Sometimes the condition is to pay directly to the seller. I advise against that. I explain the risks, but in the end the buyer always decides. Some agents don't even mention the escrow account, although it exists in Italy. The reason: the agent can send his commission invoice after the preliminary contract. If the deposit stays with the notary for three or four months until the deed, there is sometimes resistance. Legally, the agent may claim his commission right after the preliminary contract. In practice, often only half is due at the preliminary contract, or he waits until the deed. You can see how different the interests can be.

Rainer: Should lawyers and agents then rather keep out of each other's way?

Giovanna: On the contrary, the lawyer should work with agents. But their life becomes a little more complicated with a lawyer, because not everything is always said, and the lawyer wants to explain everything. I would rather word that carefully.

Rainer: Understood, we'll look at that together. Let's move on to documents: which documents should a buyer ask the seller for?

Giovanna: Normally the buyer receives a cadastral extract, the visura catastale, and the floor plans, the planimetrie. But usually the buyer instructs me straight away, because he can't judge whether these documents are sufficient and what they mean. He sees numbers, a map, a floor plan.

Patrick: That sounds like enough information at first.

Giovanna: An example: recently I was shown floor plans. On the ground floor it said “cellar” and “storage room”, on the first floor rooms, bathroom, kitchen. The buyer hadn't understood that the ground floor was not legally registered as living space. A change of use, the cambio di destinazione d'uso, costs around 7,000 to 10,000 euros. That was not included in the asking price. The seller has an interest in simply handing over the plans. I have an interest in explaining them. And then the buyer decides, but with full knowledge.

Rainer: And with other documents?

Giovanna: The lawyer usually obtains those directly, because they also require understanding. If a property has a mortgage or is subject to enforcement proceedings, the foreign client just sees words. He doesn't understand the legal consequences. Every property is unique. At the first meeting I explain the general procedure, which is the same for everyone. After that we go into the details of the specific property, with its critical points and solutions.

Patrick: One thing that helped us a lot was the power of attorney. We couldn't travel to Italy for every step. You signed the deed of sale for us.

Giovanna: Yes, with a procura, a power of attorney for a specific act. No general power of attorney is needed for that. Usually the buyer is represented before the notary, for the purchase, for the mortgage, or for both. For the mortgage it is almost a requirement, because the loan agreement is very complex and comes with many annexes. If the buyer were there in person, everything would have to be translated.

Patrick: For us that would have been expensive. We would have had to have the whole deed translated into German, with a German notary's stamp, sent back and translated again, and then fly over ourselves to sign. That would have cost us thousands of euros. With the power of attorney it was faster and much cheaper.

Giovanna: For the purchase, the power of attorney is simple. It is much more complex for the loan, because as the representative I have to protect myself and inform the client about every detail. That is why I always share the English version, even when the deed is in Italian, so the client knows exactly what I am signing. When I sign, I do not sign as Giovanna Salvucci but in the name and on behalf of the client. All legal effects fall on him. That is why I go through every clause, the conditions and the interest rates with him.

Rainer: Many people dream of a pool when buying a house. How do you find out beforehand whether you can build one?

Giovanna: I put a condition in the contract. There is time between the preliminary contract and the deed, and I use it to apply for planning permission for the pool. The application has to be made in the seller's name, because according to the official records he is the owner. Of course the seller doesn't want to pay anything. So the buyer hires a surveyor, pays him, submits the project and applies for permission in the seller's name. The deed is postponed until the condition is met.

Rainer: And if the municipality says no?

Giovanna: That is rare. Only a few municipalities don't allow pools, or only not in certain zones, for example nature reserves or because of geological problems. Normally you get the permit.

Patrick: We did exactly that with our house. Our representatives submitted the application. And it really matters, because otherwise you find out after signing, after the transfer and after getting the keys, that you can't build the pool here, or not the way you wanted. Then there is disappointment or high costs. The same goes for a ruin you want to restore.

Giovanna: Verbal assurances from the seller or the agent don't help later. If the municipality refuses the permit, there is nothing you can do after the purchase. With the condition in the preliminary contract you are protected. You show serious interest, sign, pay the agreed deposit, and in the end you only buy if the permit for exactly that pool is in place. It works the same for a portico, if you are not sure whether the volume allows it. Or for an old municipal road that runs across your land on the map, even though perhaps nobody has used it for decades. The procedure for that is somewhat long and expensive. But if you set as a condition that the seller pays for its removal and the correction of the map, that is of course better for the buyer. It always depends on the individual case.

Rainer: What is the biggest mistake a buyer can make?

Giovanna: There are many. Agents should never say anything false, but they can leave out the truth. It could be a road, a pre-emption right, a dispute with the neighbour that you only discover later, or a problem with a donation. Every contract has potential mistakes. An agent has neither the competence nor the mandate to inform in detail and find solutions.

Rainer: So never buy without a lawyer?

Giovanna: It is possible to buy without a lawyer if the case is simple. But you never know beforehand whether it will stay simple and whether you will end up in a legal dispute. And foreigners understandably worry about the Italian justice system. That is a big risk and should absolutely be avoided.

Patrick: Is there a case where it isn't possible at all without a lawyer?

Giovanna: Yes, when the property is being sold at a court auction. Then creditors are involved, there are claims on the property, a judge and a special procedure. It is complex and takes a long time. But whoever can wait can benefit greatly, because the price is well below the usual level. Everyone is put off by court, judge and a long list of creditors. But when there is a solution, even if it takes time, you can gain a real advantage.

Patrick: Finally, something personal: you have always lived in the Marche. What do you love about it here?

Giovanna: I was away for a while in Rome for my studies, but I love the Marche because we have everything here: the sea, the Sibillini mountains, you can go skiing and you are quickly at the mountains or the sea. There are many characteristic towns with special sights. Many properties are for sale and you can find very good investments: not only a house for your own needs, but also holiday homes to use or to rent out in summer. That is why we recommend the Marche.

Patrick: It is the same for us. We have been here for three years now and still keep discovering new things. This summer we went to the opera in Macerata for the first time. We haven't been to the Sibillini mountains at all yet, although everybody says you have to go there, eat the pasta and drink the wine. We are usually only here for ten days or two weeks.

Giovanna: It sounds strange, but I often marvel myself. Even I, who have always lived here, don't know the Marche perfectly. Every time it is a discovery, with little villages and fantastic views. People travel as far as Thailand or Vietnam and haven't seen the beauty right on their doorstep. There is a lot to see in the Marche.

Patrick: When our children finish school, we want to spend more time here. Maybe another small apartment by the sea.

Giovanna: I would highly recommend that.

Patrick & Rainer: Giovanna, thank you very much for the conversation.

Giovanna Salvucci is a lawyer with a practice in Civitanova Marche and has advised foreign buyers on property purchases in Italy for around 30 years.

Photos: Trovara.